Good quality kibble diets make raw uncessary?
The Whole Dog Journal [ref] regularly publishes a list of the top 20 commercial foods that includes some top brands from smaller companies. All the health problems associated with commercial grain-based food are related to lower quality, “supermarket” brand kibbles, right? Besides, the commercial grain-based pet food industry has been taking steps forward in terms of pet nutrition, haven't they? There is a good variety of healthy, “premium” grain-based kibble offerings on the market, and feeding one of these to our pets does reap certain benefits when compared to their cheaper-fed counterparts (feed less food, smaller stool size, better coats, better energy, etc.). Granted, if you feed a premium kibble then you are feeding your pet a better quality food, but could your pet be fed even better food? Is a premium grain-based kibble an appropriate food for your pets?
The following information is meant as a general guideline, and has been researched from other sources.
There are several high-quality kibble products on the market today, but there are still several significant issues that set raw diets apart from these premium grain-based kibble. Let us look at several of the issues posed by premium grain-based kibble.
- It is still a processed food. This means it has still been rendered, overly cooked, overly processed, and still has artificial vitamins and supplements added to it. Despite the claims of what went into this food at the start, this means the ingredients are still of a poorer quality when compared to fresh, whole, raw foods, and that problems associated with artificial vitamins and minerals still exist: erratic growth patterns, growth occurring too fast, the body not utilizing the nutrients as well, etc. While the better quality foods certainly do start with better materials, after processing these 'food' materials are still of a lesser quality compared to the fresh, raw, real thing.
- It still is an unnatural food for our pets. Our dogs and cats are not designed to eat processed food pellets regardless of how good of quality these processed grain-based food pellets are. Most premium grain-based kibble would be like us eating a “premium” cereal day in and day out; the premium cereal has to be better for us than one of those cheaper cereals, right?
- Premium grain-based kibble still has a bunch of ingredients our pets do not need and / or cannot utilise. Many premium grain-based kibble contain a relatively small amount of meat, usually from “human quality” sources, but then it is rendered into an unrecognisable “foodstuff”, even if meat is listed as the first ingredient, because the rest of the ingredients combined far outweigh the presence of the meat our fur kids need. Remember, meat, unless it says “meat meal”, is listed according to its wet weight. When all that water has been cooked out of it, meat places considerably further down on the ingredients list. Just read some of the labels. Some sort of meat will be listed, but it is then followed by all sorts of grains that are usually touted as more highly digestible than corn or wheat (rice, oats, barley, millet, etc.), vegetables (yams, potatoes, carrots, sweet potatoes, etc.), fruits (apples, pears, etc.) and supplements (kelp powder, spirulina, lactobacillus bacteria, etc.), not to mention all the artificial vitamins and minerals that need to be added. Of course, the presence of the vegetables, fruits, and supplements theoretically means that less artificial vitamins and minerals can be added because the nutrients can be obtained from natural sources, but how many of these natural sources are actually available to your fur kids? How much of these natural nutrients are destroyed and rendered ineffective by the cooking process? Even with high quality brands that contain a high proportion of meat and no grain (it uses potatoes, which are starchy and metabolise as such), the processed meat still is inferior to the fresh, real thing. Think of a processed, cooked orange versus a fresh, whole orange. Which one is better?
- The issue of periodontal disease still prevails. Your fur kids still do not get the beneficial, necessary teeth cleaning at each meal, so the problem of a bacteria-laden mouth that stinks and provides a gateway for bacteria, toxins, and collagenases to enter the body still exists. This is, after all, one of the best and biggest reasons we promote feeding a raw diet with raw meaty bones every now and again.
- Your four legged friends still lack the wonderful and necessary physical, mental, and emotional workout provided by raw meaty bones. Although it is being fed a premium grain-based kibble, your fur kid can undoubtedly still finish its meal in record time, rather than having to work at its food for a half an hour or more. Again, this translates to the body not being fully prepared to receive food and digest it, so the food will just sit in your fur kids’ stomach until the parasympathetic nervous system kicks everything into gear.
- Some premium grain-based kibble is often more expensive that natural, fresh, raw food. If you are dishing out that much money for a “premium” processed pet food, why not feed fresh, whole, raw food sources for less?
- You still have no control over what goes into your pet's body. Can you be certain that what is on the ingredients list is what actually enters your pet's body? Can you be certain of the quality of the ingredients? What happened to these ingredients during the cooking process?
The primary question still remains: how is a processed commercial grain-based pet food better for our animals than fresh, whole, raw foods?
It is for these reasons, and many more, that many raw feeders consider premium grain-based kibble fruitless expenditure. This includes those so-called “therapeutic diets” available only through veterinarians. The commercial pet food industry and veterinary community simply developed another artificial food to cover up and “fix” the problems created by other commercial, artificial grain-based pet foods. Why not treat the problems at their source? In this respect, the commercial grain-based pet food companies and the traditional veterinary community have drastically missed the mark, and it is our pets that must suffer for it. What sense does it make to simply switch an ailing pet onto another commercial, artificial grain-based pet food when similar foods caused the problems it was having in the first place?
With the growing number of food allergies pet have, the commercial grain-based pet food industry has been becoming more and more creative, trying to find new protein and grain sources to make new “hypoallergenic” kibble. Have they even once considered WHY the pets were having allergy problems to the ingredients in their foods to begin with? Ironically enough, pets switched to a raw diet can often eat the same meats that caused their allergies originally, because the meats are raw and not cooked. The cooking process changes the protein structures, and it is these changed, cooked proteins to which the body has an allergic reaction.
We agree, not all kibble are created equal ..
We do acknowledge that for some pet parents and guardians, convenience is an important factor when considering their fur kids' nutritional requirements due to many social and environmental factors. We therefore recommend Orijen as alternatives to a natural raw diet. Orijen (produced by Champion Foods [ref] in Canada) is the only commercial kibble that we are aware of, and available in South Africa, that is based on biologically specie appropriate raw food principles, packaged for your convenience. So don't despair if you cannot feed fresh raw, you can safely substitute with their original freeze dried medallions.
Some of this work was adapted from the works published by Carissa Kuehn, Myths of Raw Feed, http://rawfed.com/myths/.
Additional Articles and Videos
Good reference articles & videos further reading available at:
- Clark, W.R., Hypersensitivity and Allergy, in At War Within: The double edged sword of immunity, 1995, New York, Oxford University Press (Amazon);
- Allergies and Itchy Skin by Dr Bruce Syme (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s5BAD85am20)
- Dog Allergy and Skin Problem Interview by Dr Bruce Syme (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S3FCl11dN_k)
- Raw Diets and Allergic Reactions & Food Intolerances (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVGNMnHgUbs)
- Raw Diets and Skin Conditions by Dr Vicky Payne (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXGOSng1NZ0)